The cosmological necklace problem

Abstract

We investigate 3d de Sitter axion wormholes that contribute to the no-boundary density matrix. We identify cosmological necklace solutions: an infinite series of Euclidean saddles corresponding with repeated bounces. This results in an unbound gravitational entropy, and a divergent path integral. To remedy this, we study the gravitational path integral using a (mostly) Lorentzian lapse contour. Within a minisuperspace steepest-descent analysis, we find that a single necklace dominates, leading to a finite entropy. A crucial element is to take into account an pa Ñ ´aq redundancy in the FLRW path integral, where a is the scale factor. Surprisingly, the dominant solution is not purely Euclidean. Its entropy turns out to be independent of the axion flux, and equals the empty de Sitter entropy. We also study higher-dimensional necklaces, sourced by either an axion flux or by Yang-Mills instantons, and argue for qualitatively similar results: the single necklace solution dominates along a Lorentzian lapse contour.